Different Problem, Same Answer

Different Problem - Same Answer!

Introduction

This website provides problem-solving activities whereby pupils will have a different worksheet to that of their neighbour yet they will arrive at the same answer. All of the activities have a worked solution (or solutions). The picture above is adapted from one of the activities.

How to use the Resources

To help navigation, each resource is allocated to a year group. I developed the resources whilst teaching at The Manchester Grammar School and I have allocated the resources assuming top sets in those year groups at the school. But this is quite arbitrary and as a teacher you will know best what your classes are capable of and what they will benefit from. So please take the allocations with a huge pinch of salt.

Some resources can be used as an introduction to a topic ('Sine Rule Discovery' and 'Angle at centre, Angle on Arc', for example) but generally they should be used when a certain level of proficiency in a topic (or topics) has been achieved by the class.

My suggestion is that teachers search through the short descriptions for a topic or sort by year group to find an activity. Then review the PowerPoint to familiarise themselves with the activity and then print the worksheets from the PDF file provided. The worksheets will already be in 1-up, 2-up or 4-up format, as appropriate, so just a simple print followed by some guillotining is required. For visually impaired pupils (or translation to another language, for example) all of the worksheets are provided at the end of the PowerPoint.

For larger class sizes you may require some duplicate worksheets. However, it should be easy to ensure each worksheet is different to that of its neighbour.

I am happy to run a workshop for the mathematics department at your school to demonstrate the resources and navigation of the website. There would be no fee, just reasonable expenses. If interested, please email me to start the conversation.

Closing remarks

Having stated that within an activity all the worksheets provide the same answer, that's not quite true. That's because once pupils have experienced a few of the problems they'll know that the answers are the same for the whole class. For this reason, a number of activities have different answers but each answer can be easily obtained by the teacher by doing something simple like multiplying two numbers on the worksheet together. This information is included in a 'Note to Teacher' slide in the Powerpoint.

Because not all of the answers are the same within an activity but they are related in some way the original name for my resources was 'Something In Common' or 'SIC' for short and this website represents a re-branding of those resources. That is why you will see 'SIC_nn' identifiers on the worksheets where 'nn' represents the number of the activity. 'Different Problem - Same Answer' captures the imagination more and better conveys the essence of the resources.

Not all of the resources are my own original creation. Inevitably, I have borrowed and adapted some resources made by other people and organisations and adapted them to fit in with my theme by focusing on their invariant properties. Where I have done so I have given credit for it.

All feedback or ideas for new activities are warmly welcomed.

John Burke
Mathematics Teacher (retired, formerly at The Manchester Grammar School)
burkejjdr@gmail.com

Click on a column header to sort on that column. Click again to reverse the sort.
No. Title Short description Earliest Year Group (top set) Image of Worksheet or activity Worksheets Presentation Supporting material 1 Supporting material 2 Supporting material 3
1 Think of a Number A simple game that finishes on 1, whatever your starting number. Leads to creating expressions and proof. No worksheets are required.Think of a Number B_
Year 8
x_B_x
SIC_1.png download(PowerPoint)
2 Sine Rule Discovery Measure the sides and angles and calculate the ratios. All ratios in the class are the same, yet all of the triangles are different.Sine Rule Discovery E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_2.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
3 Parallelogram in Quadrilateral - Grid Bisect the sides of a quadrilateral to get a parallelogram (Varignon's Theorem). All quadrilaterals are different but all parallelograms are identical. The grid allows easy bisection.Parallelogram in Quadrilateral - Grid B_
Year 8
x_B_x
SIC_3.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
4 Parallelogram in Quadrilateral - Compass Bisect the sides of a quadrilateral to get a parallelogram. All quadrilaterals are different but all parallelograms are identical. A compass will be needed to bisect the sides.Parallelogram in Quadrilateral - Compass C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_4.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
5 A Circle Property RISP 9. Pupils choose certain values and draw their own circle. All circles go through the origin.A Circle Property F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_5.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
6 Annulus Volume of Revolution Pupils are given different segments of circles and asked to calculate their volumes of revolution. They all have the same volume.Annulus Volume of Revolution I
Year 1 - Further Pure
x_R_x
SIC_6.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Excel) download(Autograph)
7 Trapezium and Diagonals Pupils need to work out the area of two triangles given the area of two others which all fit in a trapezium. This problem acts as a good reminder that a triangle's area does not change as the apex moves parallel to the base. In solving this problem many pupils will use similarity, but there is a much more elegant solution.Trapezium and Diagonals C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_7.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
8 Four Crescents Four crescents are drawn around a rectangle. All rectangles are different and the area of the crescents is equal to that of the rectangle. Surd (area = 1) and non-surd (area = 900) versions available.Four Crescents E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_8.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Scratch)
9 Brackets out, Brackets in RISP 3. Pupils have to simplify some algebra, that they have generated. All have the factor (x+1).Brackets out, Brackets in F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_9.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Excel)
10 Magic Bag nRich. An algebra task thinly disguised as a probability question. The pupils have to determine the number of white balls in a bag. There are two answers! Triangular numbers are involved.Magic Bag H
Year 1 - Statistics
x_S_x
SIC_10.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
11 Triangle xy Area Work out the area of a triangle with an inscribed circle. Answers are all different but easily calculated from the given parameters.Triangle xy Area E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_11.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
12 Quad Tessellate Get pupils to draw a quadrilateral that they think will not tessellate. Then reproduce it using the Geogebra file and show that it does. Then show a picture proof. No worksheet is required.Quad Tessellate A_
Year 7
x_A_x
SIC_12.png download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra) download(Geogebra)
13 A Geometric Progression Problem From clues given about the second and fourth terms of a geometric progression the pupils have to work out the possible solutions for the first term and common ratio.A Geometric Progression Problem F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_13.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
14 Integration Stretch A parabola is stretched - calculate the stretch factor to achieve the area bounded between the two. All parabolas are different but the stretch factors are the same.Integration Stretch J
Year 2 - Pure
x_T_x
SIC_14.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra) download(Geogebra) openbox4.png(Adobe PDF)
15 Magic Fractions nRich. Using their own numbers (following a rule) the pupils form fractions and carry out operations on them. All answers are the same. No worksheet is required.Magic Fractions A_
Year 7
x_A_x
SIC_15.png download(PowerPoint)
16 Angle at Centre, Angle on Arc Discovery of two circle theorems. Pupils mark out angles on a chord and cut them out and compare.Angle at Centre, Angle on Arc D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_16.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
17 Multi-Simultaneous Pupils are presented with a number of simultaneous equations to solve. How quickly will they spot that they only need to select one pair? How many will select the easiest pair rather than just the first two in the list?.......Multi-Simultaneous D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_17.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Excel)
18 Polygon in Annulus Pupils need to work out the area of a couple of rings with different dimensions - but the same area.Polygon in Annulus D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_18.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
19 Cubic Tangent Circle Pupils need to work out the equation of a cubic and draw a tangent at a specific place. All tangents should go through the first root.Cubic Tangent Circle F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_19.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
20 Hyper Parabola Pupils need to find out where a parabola and a hyperbola just touch. This activity reinforces the notion of double roots and discriminant = 0.Hyper Parabola F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_20.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
21 Leonardo of Pisa Pupils are given the nth term of a sequence and are asked to find specific (non consecutive) terms in the sequence. It is the Fibonacci sequence. The task involves surds and indices. Then they are asked to prove that the ratio of consecutive terms tends to the golden ratio.Leonardo of Pisa D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_21.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Excel)
22 The Shortest Race You have to run from tree A to tree B whilst touching a fence. Where should you touch the fence to minimise the distance you have to run?The Shortest Race J
Year 2 - Pure
x_T_x
SIC_22.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
23 A Fractional Sequence An inductive formula is given with each pupil having different starting values. They have to find the 11th and 12th terms. The sequence loops (but they don't know that) so they don't need to go that far. Then, of course, they have to prove it always loops!A Fractional Sequence F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_23.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
24 Area between Parabolas An integration activity around the area bounded by two parpabolas. Some pupils are confused if the area straddles the x-axis. This activity adresses this.Area between Parabolas F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_24.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
25 Crossed Lines This tests the pupils' knowledge of straight line graphs and y=mx+c and the significance of gradients of perpendicular lines.Crossed Lines D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_25.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
26 Shoot the Monkey Projectiles. You want to shoot a monkey hanging in a tree. But he's a cheeky monkey and at the exact moment you fire, he lets go and falls to the ground. Knowing this, where should you aim to be sure of hitting your target?Shoot the Monkey K
Year 2 - Mechanics
x_U_x
SIC_26.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
27 Skew Lines Skew lines in 3D space in vector form. How close do they get?Skew Lines J
Year 2 - Pure
x_T_x
SIC_27.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
28 Survey Plot Imagine you needed to remove one metre depth of topsoil from a new building plot. What volume does this represent? How many wagons will you need, etc? By approximating this area to a polygon (where you know the coordinates of the vertices) makes the task very easy (even easier with a spreadsheet).Survey Plot F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_28.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Excel) download(Geogebra)
29 Volume of Tetrahedron Given the 3D coordinates of four points what is the volume of the tetrahedron that is formed by joining them with line segments? This brings together just about everything they need to know about vectors and so is a good revision task. The solution does not use the triple product. All the volumes are the same.Volume of Tetrahedron J
Year 2 - Pure
x_T_x
SIC_29.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Excel) download(Autograph) download(Autograph)
30 Parabola in Parallelogram Given certain facts about a parabola the pupils have to determine its equation. Then they need to integrate the function to work out ratios of areas. There is a neat solution that makes it very easy to do - which you can show them at the end. A further extension is to challenge them to do it without integration.Parabola in Parallelogram F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_30.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Excel)
31 Straight Line A very simple (but illuminating) task where pupils follow simple instructions and generate the equation of a straight line from consideration of areas of triangles. Each equation is different but easy for the teacher to ascertain the answer by visual inspection.Straight Line B_
Year 8
x_B_x
SIC_31.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
32 How Close? A coordinate geometry task. Pupils have the coordinates of two points on a line. How close is this line to a third point? All pairs of coordinates are different but lie on three different lines - but the closest distance is the same for all.How Close? F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_32.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
33 Target Range Simple projectiles problem. Given two points on a trajectory the pupils need to ascertain range, angle of elevation and muzzle velocity. A good test to see if they can remember how to do it from first principles.Target Range K
Year 2 - Mechanics
x_U_x
SIC_33.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
34 L-centre Hands-on activity to find the centre of mass of an L-shaped plane figure by construction only. But there is something special about them all - each centre of mass is at the inner elbow of the L. Can the pupils work out why this is? The golden ratio is involved.L-centre N
Year 2 - Further Mechanics
x_U_x
SIC_34.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
35 Strange Guys Classic problem involving masts and guy ropes solved using the application of similar triangles. The activity brings out the fact that the distance between the masts is irrelelvant to the question posed. All the answers are the same (90 m). Strange Guys C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_35.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
36 Quadthagoras! Problem involving forming and solving a quadratic equation. Conceptually not very hard but pupils will need knowledge of the quadratic formula, because although all of the quadratics can be factorised they can be tricky due to coefficients greater than 1. Can the pupils work out how all the answers are the same?Quadthagoras! D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_36.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
37 Find f(2) A slightly cryptic question based on a quadratic function. Not too difficult but a little different from the norm. As an extension you could ask the pupils to come up with their own parameters that give the same solution.Find f(2) F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_37.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
38 Awkward Triangle Given the side lengths of a scalene triangle (in surd form) can the pupils work out its area? Tests use of the Cosine Rule and multiplication and simplification of surds. For interest, Heron's formula is also used to solve the problem.Awkward Triangle E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_38.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
39 Letter Wheel Pupils have to work out how much the last wheel of five connected wheels turns when told how much the first wheel turns. Sixteen different answers but teacher knows each answer from information coded in the worksheeet. Can introduce modulo arithmetic.Letter Wheel B_
Year 8
x_B_x
SIC_39.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Scratch)
40 Quadratic Segments Pupils have to work out the area of three segments formed by chords of equal horizontal widths drawn on a parabola. Interestingly, this area is invariant for a given width. They discover this and then hopefully prove it.Quadratic Segments J
Year 2 - Pure
x_T_x
SIC_40.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
41 Cross Bear! Three bears start scoffing porridge at different rates and then start scoffing each other's. Pupils have to work out the individual rates. Teacher can find the answer encoded in the worksheeet by multiplying a number by 10.Cross Bear! C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_41.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
42 The Obedient Ray A light ray bounces between two mirrors and retraces its steps. The angle (to be determined) between the mirrors is the same but the height of each ray is different. Simple geometry yields the answer but pupils are invited to look at a more general case. Pupils may not know about the law of reflection but it is not a great stretch of the imagination.The Obedient Ray E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_42.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
43 Pick a Polygon Pupils discover Pick's Theorem. Each worksheet has different polygons but polygons allocated to a given letter have the same area. They are invited to draw more polygons and discover the formula for the area.Pick a Polygon B_
Year 8
x_B_x
SIC_43.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Word)
44 Sea Shell Product Pupils discover an intriguing result - the product of the lengths of the chords equals the number of equally spaced dots on the circle. Quite simple trigonometry and lengths of sides of triangles involving surds. The proof of the result will be beyond them. See task no. 84, aimed at Further Mathematicians, for the proof.Sea Shell Product D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_44.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
45 Piscatorial Percentages A counter-intuitive result involving percentages. It's a nice little problem to solve algebraically but there is also a very simple way to do it which makes it even more worth doing. I couldn't resist using some Escher artwork.Piscatorial Percentages C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_45.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
46 Squaring the Rectangle Pupils are asked to construct a square with area equal to a given rectangle, using construction methods only. Gives practice in constructions and application of the intersecting chords theorem. Leads to determining the square root of a number by construction.Squaring the Rectangle D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_46.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
47 How Many Sides? On the face of it this looks like a very tricky problem but in fact it is quite straightforward, only requiring knowledge of external angles and the sum of angles in a triangle! Teacher can easily infer the answer and there is an interesting result at the end.How Many Sides? D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_47.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
48 Three Circles and a Tangent Pupils seem to be fazed when they first look at this problem, so it's worth doing. It only requires Pythagoras' Theorem (like most Sangaku problems). There is a neat answer to the general case.Three Circles and a Tangent D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_48.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
49 What's the Sine Rule Ratio? Pupils are asked to use their knowledge of sine rule, cosine rule and even a circle theorem or two to determine angles and lengths in a triangle.What's the Sine Rule Ratio? E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_49.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
50 Misprints Do Hapen Two proof-readers find errors in the same manuscript - but not all the same ones. How many are likely to have been missed by both? This problem seems intractable at first but is quite straightforward if you keep a clear head. The pupils should be challenged to create a new worksheet with the same answer, 2.Misprints Do Hapen H
Year 1 - Statistics
x_S_x
SIC_50.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
51 Equal Tangents This is a mixture of loci and coordinate geometry. It demonstrates a pleasing result that many teachers do not know about and its solution is delightfully simple and totally accessible, requiring no more than Pythagoras and a circle theorem.Equal Tangents F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_51.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
52 Criss-crossing An activity that hopefully tests their knowledge on everything they might need to know about straight lines: y=mx+c, gradient of perpendicular, intersection and simultaneous equations, distance between two points and calculating the midpoint of two points.Criss-crossing D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_52.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
53 Determine the Diagonals An activity that combines problem solving with the cosine rule. One of the diagonals is obvious, the other less so. Teacher can get the answer by simply adding two lengths, the pupils will need to work it out. All the quadrilaterals exhibit a special case of Ptolemy's theorem, which can be introduced for enrichment.Determine the Diagonals E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_53.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
54 Ratio of Tans Given seemingly random triangles the pupils need to calculate the ratio of the tangents of two named angles. For every triangle the answer is 2. They need to understand a little coordinate geometry, how to get sine from tangent, use the sine rule. Proof of the answer requires a circle theorem and some geometry.Ratio of Tans J
Year 2 - Pure
x_T_x
SIC_54.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
55 Triangle Tan Product and Sum Pupils are given triangles (whose sides follow a pattern but this is just a red herring) and they must determine the product of the tan of each angle and the sum of the tan of each angle. Why are they equal? Were the triangles special? They must investigate the general case and prove this identity that doesn't seem very well known.Triangle Tan Product and Sum J
Year 2 - Pure
x_T_x
SIC_55.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
56 Sloping Triangle Pupils are given a scalene triangle on a grid and they have to work out its area. Counting squares is awkward and so they need to add triangles, rectangles or trapeziums and determine the area by area subtraction. But there is a neat way to work out the area with just one area calculation. Can they find it?Sloping Triangle C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_56.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
57 Wedged Triangles Pupils are given two triangles that are wedged between a reciprocal curve and the x and y axes. Their job is to work out their areas (which are equal to each other and easy for the teacher to ascertain). Can they prove why they are equal? Involves diffferentiation and equations of straight lines.Wedged Triangles E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_57.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) openbox4.png(Adobe PDF)
58 Straight Line and Circle A very simple (but illuminating) task where pupils have to find the equation of a straight line that is tangential to an unknown circle centred on the origin. They are given the coordinates of a single point on the line so it ties a few concepts together. The coordinates appear in the answer, making it easy for teacher!Straight Line and Circle E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_58.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
59 What's f(500)? Problem solving activity taken from the UK Mathematics Trust Senior Mathematics Challenge 2015. I have simply created additional starting points that all end up with the same answer.What's f(500)? F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_59.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
60 Two Crescents and a Triangle A problem solving activity using area of the circle and triangle and bringing them together using Pythagoras. All answers are different but very easy for the teacher to know the answer from numbers on the worksheet. Ends with the realisation that Pythagoras does not have to have "squares".Two Crescents and a Triangle D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_60.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
61 4 Squared Fractions Practice with fractions. An activity that gives an unexpected result with fraction addition/subtraction/squaring. Because of the pattern of numbers used the answer is always 4. This is a surprising result which the pupils then need to prove.4 Squared Fractions D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_61.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
62 Three Triangles and a Square Practice with surds and a little problem solving. Pupils have to find missing lengths in triangles to eventually obtain the side of the square (which is the same for all worksheets).Three Triangles and a Square D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_62.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
63 An interesting pair of Simultaneous Equations Practice with non-linear simultaneous equations with disguised circles. Two circles intersect a given line at the same points. Ends with an unusual result - subtracting the circle equations gives the equation of the common chord (which is the given straight line).An interesting pair of Simultaneous Equations F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_63.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
64 Cuboid Faces Problem solving activity taken from nRich. Pupils need to determine the volume of a cuboid given only the areas of it faces. There is a nice alternative solution twist at the end.Cuboid Faces D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_64.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
65 Heads will roll! A winter-themed version of the classic rolling circles problem that many are probably unaware of.Heads will roll! C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_65.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
66 Triangle Multiple One of those problems where it looks like that you don't have enough information. A little thought shows that it only requires knowledge of the area of triangles. There is a nice twist at the end where changing one of the values does not affect the answer. Many thanks to ATM's "Forty Harder Problems for the Classroom".Triangle Multiple E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_66.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
67 Partial Mean A problem to see if the pupils really do understand how to calculate means of numbers. Another rich resource taken from nRich. Some big numbers are involved but you can challenge them to solve it without a calculator (easy if you know about the difference of two squares).Partial Mean C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_67.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
68 Train Length A classic speed-distance-time problem which exemplifies reading the question properly and is good practice at problem solving. The equation is easy to solve, but only if you form it correctly. The answer is half the train tunnel length - can they work out why this is the case? A simple, accessible proof is all that is required.Train Length G
Year 1 - Mechanics
x_S_x
SIC_68.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
69 The Square of the Perpendicular A problem solving resource which utilises Pythagoras and circle theorems (but not obviously) to work out the area of a specially constructed quadrilateral. Pupils are invited to look at the general case to explain their findings. The idea for this resource came from a UKMT Senior Kangaroo paper.The Square of the Perpendicular J
Year 2 - Pure
x_T_x
SIC_69.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
70 What's f(20nn)? An example of where calculators can let you down! Pupils have to simply evaluate a given function but they won't achieve the required level of accuracy by calculation. Resorting to algebra (with a link to rationalising surds) gives the correct answer.What's f(20nn)? E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_70.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
71 Ramanujan Junction This activity tests pupils' knowledge of gradients, straight line graphs and simultaneous equations (and the link with crossing lines). The answer lies in the title, being (17,29). The lines on each worksheet are the same, only the coordinates differ.Ramanujan Junction D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_71.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
72 Dissected Parallelogram Most pupils will have no clue as to how to start this problem. Teacher will probably need to scaffold with the idea that shearing a shape does not change its area. So the parallelogram is mapped to a rectangle. The problem reduces to knowledge of areas of triangles.Dissected Parallelogram D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_72.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
73 Overlapping Semicircles This activity brings together a circle theorem, Pythagoras and proof. Similarity can also be used and a neat way using the intersecting chords theorem is also shown. All answers are the same (pi) and the pupils are invited to prove it, reproducing their calcualtions with letters in place of numbers.Overlapping Semicircles E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_73.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
74 How Many Right-Angled Triangles? Most pupils will use Pythagoras to solve this problem. But it is instructive to use gradients of perpendicular lines to solve it also. The result surprises many (there are four such triangles) and a circle theorem explains why. An extension utilises the discriminant to find a unique solution.How Many Right-Angled Triangles? F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_74.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
75 How Tall the Triangle? Most pupils will find this a bit tricky at first because they are unlikely to have seen anything like it before so it is a good problem solving activity. It utilises a really neat result so that Teacher only needs to sum the three lengths to arrive at the unique answer. The proof is not difficult.How Tall the Triangle? F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_75.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
76 Baffling Integrals? Pupils are given two integrals to evaluate. They do not look related at first sight but they evaluate to the same value. In fact, the whole class get the same result and they are invited to investigate why. This activity links transformations and the affect (or not) on areas.Baffling Integrals? F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_76.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
77 Four Triangular Areas Pupils are given the coordinates of the vertices of four triangles and they have to calculate their areas. They are all the same. But why, what links them? They bisect the same parallelogram and so all have the same area. Translations are involved in the analysis. An exploration of triangular areas activity is suggested.Four Triangular Areas C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_77.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
78 Wedged Chord This is a minimal information problem: there is only one number given! At first sight pupils will wonder if it is solvable at all. A great example of being stuck. The solution can be found using the intersecting chords theorem. 6th formers may use a circle theorem and a double angle formula. There is a twist at the end.Wedged Chord E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_78.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
79 Rotated Square If the pupils have covered the Cosine Rule they may well set about calculating angles, which could be good revision. However, that is not necessary, and the given lengths are irrelevant! There is a nice solution using a circle theorem.Rotated Square E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_79.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
80 Angle between the Chords This is an example of misdirection. Triangles can be drawn and angles calculated to arrive at the answer (and did they use their calculator correctly and get an exact, not "rounds to", answer?). But none of that is necessary. By planning your way through this problem you find that the answer is invariant, with a few ways to solve it.Angle between the Chords E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_80.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
81 Three Equilateral Triangles Nothing too advanced here except the need to problem solve. Simple trigonometry is involved as well as spotting the need to use Pythagoras' Theorem. The result is unexpected and makes it easy for Teacher to know if they got it right. There is an animation in Geogebra to convince pupils of the result.Three Equilateral Triangles F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_81.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
82 Tim and Tan Not too difficult a puzzle to solve but the wow factor is that all of their answers are the same. This is quite powerful at this age. So the question to the class is "How are all the answers the same?". This introduces some algebra to prove the general case.Tim and Tan A_
Year 7
x_A_x
SIC_82.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
83 Three Squares and a Semicircle This is one of those nice problems where most pupils will think that here isn't enough information to go on. Two solutions (using the intersecting chords theorem and Pythagoras) are shown. The numbers have been chosen to give some practice using surds and it is very easy for the teacher to know the answer to each worksheet.Three Squares and a Semicircle D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_83.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
84 Sea Shell Product Pupils discover an intriguing result - the product of the lengths of the chords equals the number of equally spaced dots on the circle. Quite simple trigonometry and lengths of sides of triangles involving surds. The proof is very difficult, involving the nth roots of 1, and is well worth seeing.Sea Shell Product M
Year 2 - Further Pure
x_T_x
SIC_84.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
85 Solid Cone and Hemisphere A bit of history of Mathematics - working out the volume of sphere without calculus. Pupils have to work out the cross-sectional area of slices through a cone and a hemisphere, which some pupils find difficult to do. Remarkably, the sum of the areas is constant and equal to the base area of each solid. This leads into the idea of summing all of the areas to make up a volume.Solid Cone and Hemisphere E_
Year 11
x_E_x
SIC_85.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
86 Quadrilateral Angles This problem tests pupils' understanding of coordinate geometry, i.e. the gradient of a line, the distance between two points, perpendicular lines, the equation of a line through two points. It assumes that they have not covered the Cosine Rule. This is addressed in task no. 87. All the answers are the sameQuadrilateral Angles D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_86.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
87 Quadrilateral Angles This problem is identical to task no. 86 but assumes that the pupils will use the Cosine Rule to solve it.Quadrilateral Angles F
Year 1 - Pure
x_R_x
SIC_87.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
88 Quadrilateral Angles This problem is identical to task no. 86 but the pupils are encouraged to use trigonometric compound angle formulae to solve it. They are then shown how the quadrilaterals were produced and encouraged to prove the result with a little algebra.Quadrilateral Angles J
Year 2 - Pure
x_T_x
SIC_88.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)
89 Y-Intercepts This problem tests pupils' ability to determine the equation of a straight line from the coordinates of two points on it and hence the y-intercept. But there is a surprise since another pair of coordinates delivers the same result! Can they work out why? More practice on proof. Answers are not all the same but easy to work out by the teacher.Y-Intercepts C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_89.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
90 Loco Motives Three circles are packed into two rectangles in different ways and the difference between the rectangle widths is required. Not difficult, since it only requires use of Pythagoras' Theorem. But why are all the answers the same? A small amount of investigation is required and then pupils are required to prove their conjecture.Loco Motives D_
Year 10
x_D_x
SIC_90.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
91 Puzzling Perimeter - 1 At first glance it looks like there isn't enough information to solve this puzzle, but it is quite striaghtforward, really. By defining a couple of variables, an expression for the perimeter can be determined and the variables later cancel out, showing that an infinite number of rectangles have the same perimeter!Puzzling Perimeter - 1 C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_91.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
92 Puzzling Perimeter - 2 This is similar to "Puzzling Perimeter - 1" in the sense that it requires variables to be specified and equations built and then solved. All of the answers are the same. But there is a very neat solution involving translation of part of the perimeter, which would be good for the pupils to see.Puzzling Perimeter - 2 C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_92.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
93 Triangle in Triangle At first glance it looks like there isn't enough information to solve this puzzle, but it is quite straight forward, really. By defining a couple of variables, expressions for areas of triangles can be determined. Using area subtraction an expression can be formed whereby the introduced variables cancel out.Triangle in Triangle B_
Year 8
x_B_x
SIC_93.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
94 Arrowhead Perimeter Another problem that looks difficult but, in fact, isn't. It uses the fact that external tangents from a given point to a circle are equal in length. Can the pupils work that out themselves? Then it's just a case of creating some variables for unknown lengths, then forming a simple expression for the perimeter which simplifies to the answer.Arrowhead Perimeter C_
Year 9
x_C_x
SIC_94.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint) download(Geogebra)
95 Kitchen Table A fairly simple problem taken from a UKMT Junior Mathematics Challenge paper. It requires letters to be assigned to unknown lengths and then simple algebra to solve a pair of simultaneous equations.Kitchen Table B_
Year 8
x_B_x
SIC_95.png openbox4.png(Adobe PDF) download(PowerPoint)